Switching from Gusto?

A familiar team. Every payroll.

Submit online or send us your payroll details. We handle the processing, tax filings, and year-end reporting—with a familiar team to work through changes and questions.

GET A PAYROLL QUOTE

Compare the cost. Consider the service.

Example: five employees paid biweekly, in one state.

Compare Gusto Simple Gusto Plus Payroll Northeast
Payroll pricing $49 per monthPlus $6 per person per month $80 per monthPlus $12 per person per month $59 per payrollFive employees: $49 includes one employee, plus $2.50 for each of four additional employees
Year-end W-2 preparation Included Included $112.50 per year$75 plus $7.50 for each of five W-2s
Average monthly cost, including year-end* $79 $140 $137.21Annual cost divided by 12; optional integration excluded
Payroll runs Unlimited Unlimited Billed per payrollExample includes 26 biweekly payrolls
Running payroll Manage payroll in Gusto Manage payroll in Gusto Submit online or send details to our team
Payroll tax filings and payments Included Included Included
Payroll support Standard supportPriority support available at extra cost Standard supportPriority support available at extra cost A familiar payroll team

*Gusto pricing checked October 3, 2026. Gusto totals use published standard rates for five active employees: Simple $49 + (5 × $6) = $79 per month; Plus $80 + (5 × $12) = $140 per month. Promotions and add-ons are excluded. Payroll Northeast’s base rate is $49 per payroll, including one employee, plus $2.50 per additional employee. For five employees, the cost is $49 + (4 × $2.50) = $59 per payroll. This example includes 26 biweekly payrolls at $59 ($1,534) and year-end fees of $75 plus $7.50 for each of five W-2s ($112.50), totaling $1,646.50 annually. The $137.21 monthly average is rounded and is not a flat monthly billing rate. Optional QuickBooks Online integration is not included and adds $20 per month if selected. Assumes one state and five W-2s. Additional services, accounting subscriptions, and applicable taxes are excluded. Gusto Plus includes features beyond those shown, such as time tracking and multi-state payroll. Plans are not equivalent; this chart compares selected payroll features. Gusto Premium offers a named advisor and is not shown. View Gusto’s plans and features.

Let’s see what payroll with our team would look like for your business.

GET A PAYROLL QUOTE

See how switching payroll providers works →

Gusto is a trademark of its respective owner. Payroll Northeast is not affiliated with or endorsed by Gusto.